Beowulf is a classic tale
highlighting the ambiguities that exist between good and evil. What place in
our culture weaves a better narrative of heroes and villains than the American
high school? Some may argue that it’s too rudimentary to boil such complex
characters down to such trite teenage tropes, and to them I say, “You’re
probably right.” But just as Beowulf blazed bravely into battle against
Grendel, I too will face my own foe: high school social structure.
Beowulf as The Popular Guy You Didn’t Like But Could Never
Really Pinpoint Why
http://www.fanpop.com/clubs/troy-bolton/images/2142394/title/troy-photo
Maybe he was a standout athlete, or
the star child of the arts department.
Or, if he was truly a 16-year-old Renaissance man sent to walk among the
masses, both. No matter his forte, this kid was loved by your teachers, your
classmates, and probably even some of your friends. You, on the other hand,
could detect some underlying disingenuousness. You really didn’t have concrete
evidence as to why you thought this guy was secretly a jerk, so you certainly
didn’t try to rock the boat and expose him for the person you suspected he was.
There was just something about the way he walked around performing deeds of
manly courage and name-dropping his dad that rubbed you the wrong way. But, you
decided to just go with it because everyone else seemed to like him. Everyone
else but one…
Unferth as The Perpetually Angry Kid
http://meangirls.wikia.com/wiki/Gretchen_Wieners
The Perpetually Angry Kid was not-so-secretly jealous of the
popular kids and made it their mission to defame them all. Perhaps the student was born that bitter.
Perhaps they were popular until The
Popular Guy came to your town from Nebraska and took all the glory. Perhaps
The Perpetually Angry Kid killed their brother and has just been really sour about
everything since then. No matter the tragic backstory, this kid made it their
mission to let everyone know that they were
truly deserving of admiration and everyone else wasn’t good enough. How did
we learn to cope with such insufferable creatures? It can certainly be credited
to one of the most valuable of all high school treasures…
Hrothgar as The Teacher Friend
http://buffy.wikia.com/wiki/Rupert_Giles
Just as Hrothgar plays an important
role in Beowulf’s journey to heroism, The Teacher Friend played an important
role in your journey to graduation. While it’s likely that your Teacher Friend
didn’t give you the OK to slay beasts on behalf of their classroom, they
probably did let you make photocopies sometimes. And although your Teacher
Friend (hopefully) never gave you a ring, they certainly did give you sage
advice that you may or may not have implemented. One mentor’s warning against extreme tenacity
and pride is another mentor’s warning against college application
procrastination.
After this brief jaunt through the
halls of your high school memories, I hope that you, too, can see how nearly
every character has a classmate counterpart from your past. While some stories
are naturally more difficult to teen-ify, it’s certainly still easier than
trying to figure out where to sit in the high school cafeteria.
I love this comparison! I guess this would make Grendel the misfit who was left out of everything, right? Except for the eating people part, of course. I've found that putting unfamiliar characters in a familiar setting does help to demystify them a bit. That's definitely the case here.
ReplyDeleteThis is fantastic! The fact that characters in ancient stories align so well with character archetypes in contemporary ones certainly shows how little humanity has changed. There are only so many ways to tell a story after all. I never thought I'd need a Beowulf high school AU.
ReplyDeleteThis is so perfect and painfully true. These high school tropes fit the characters so well, and once I saw your point of view, it all made sense to me... I basically did go to high school with all of these people. Of course, there was less dragon-slaying and people-eating back in high school, but those are just small details. Other than that, I would say that I had classmates in these characters to a T.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed reading your comparison! It is so funny that our modern characters can still describe these ancient ones. I'm curious about who Grendel would be though. Maybe he's kind of like a variation of John Bender from The Breakfast club before they all started being friends! You have a really cool perspective on the characters. Thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteI think your comparison to different high school stereotypes is wonderful! I think the comparison also highlights the fact even stories written hundreds of years ago still tended to follow the types or stories and real-life people that you see today. It shows that no matter the time period or the place, there will always be the person who seems to better than you in every way. There will always be that elder person, who is viewed as wise beyond their years, that you do not listen to because you must know everything. To put it plainly, these characters and stories are as “old as time itself”.
ReplyDelete