Tuesday, September 27, 2016



First off, the Pardoner is quite the character. The entire time I was reading I had the constant worry that I was being lied to, but I could never quite tell if I was or not. At the very least, he obviously omits certain facts of the tales he tells to make his point. For example, on lines 505-512 the Pardoner is discussing why gluttony is humanities first ruin.  The Pardoner states that:

For whyl that Adam fasted, as I rede
He was in Paradys; and whan that he
Eet of the fruyt defended on the tree,
Anon he was outcated to wo and peyne. (508-511)

All the Pardoner talks about here is how bad Adam was for eating the forbidden fruit; this is completely opposite to the normal interpretation. Usually, it is Eve that is blamed for eating the forbidden fruit and then talking Adam into eating the fruit as well. He almost completely erases her from the picture; he does not even say her name! The Pardoner simply refers to Eve as “his [Adam’s] wyf” (505). On one had it makes me want to cheer because everything is not being blamed on the woman for once, but it also makes me want groan because he does not even mention the woman at all. 

IDK how to feel


Back to the Pardoner's tale though, how do these men expect to kill death? Do they realize how implausible that is? Are they simply still too drunk from their previous escapades to make any logical decisions? Or is the Pardoner simply pulling a fast one on us again?

Too Many Questions!

Compared to the Wife of Bath’s tale, I felt that this tale was lackluster. The thieves got what they deserved in the end and they all died because of their own selfish greed. It was a straightforward tale without much fluff or additions added to it. The tale seemed like one of the half-ass sermons he would give to people he wanted to give him money.  

Moral? Check!

Basic Plot? Check!

Anything beyond those two is simply a cherry on top for him.  

Can't he do a bit better?

 

The Pardoner's Tale and Its Irony

In medieval times,“pardoners” would sell these indulgences, kind of like certificates, in order to forgive someone’s sins and even sometimes salvation from eternal damnation. Before the Pardoner begins his tale, he admits that he is a fraud. He proudly exclaims that he is only in the pardoning business for the money and that he is guilty greed. He even says that his relics are really "ful of cloutes and of bones," (pg 234, line 348). Kind of reminds me of Matilda's father, a greedy and sly used-car salesman.



The Pardoner tells us a tale of three young men who spend all of their time drinking, swearing, and gambling, and just wasting their lives away. It is here that the Pardoner interrupts his tale to tell the group why all of these things are terrible sins forbidden by God in the Bible, but he truly believes "gret swering is a thing abhominable," (pg 240, line 631). The three young men find out that an old friend has been killed by Death, and in their drunkenness decide that they shall find Death and kill him as revenge.

Quick sidebar question: how exactly does one kill Death?!



Anyway, back to the tale.

While wandering the road looking for Death, they meet an old man who says that he had left Death under an oak tree and points them towards a grove. Under the tree they find several sacks of gold and decide to wait until nightfall to carry them away so as not to arouse suspicion. While one of the young men goes to get bread and wine, the other two plot to kill him upon his return so that they only have to split the gold two ways. Meanwhile, the man getting food and drink poisons two of the three wine bottles so that he can keep the gold all to himself. Upon his return he is stabbed by his two friends and then they drink the poisoned wine in celebration and die as well. Inconceivable!!



This tale demonstrates that greed will only lead to your own demise and that it brings out the worst in people. It is so ironic that the Pardoner is telling this tale when he is practically the embodiment of greed and intoxication. So, do you think is it possible for him to tell a tale of morals and be taken seriously?